The next frontier in cell therapy: An ethically responsible management model

News
Article
Ophthalmology Times EuropeOphthalmology Times Europe November 2023
Volume 19
Issue 09
Pages: 7 - 9

Infrastructure across Europe needs a major overhaul to optimise education and patient access in groundbreaking treatments

Next-generation treatments such as stem cell therapies and corneal endothelial cell transplantation have the potential to drastically improve the lives of patients. Leaps forward in the cell therapy arena have resulted in a proliferation of new, customised treatments that radically improve the prognosis for severe ocular disease. However, a number of institutional challenges stand in the way of these therapies being utilised effectively, according to data from one recent study.1 Significant systemic changes in blood, tissue and cell (BTC) establishments are necessary to optimise these “living medicines,” the authors said. The European Union (EU) has some existing infrastructure for these BTC establishment improvements, according to a multinational team headed by first author Joaquín Delgadillo, Banc de Sang i Teixits (BST), Edifici Dr Frederic Duran i Jordà,
Barcelona, Spain.

There is a diverse range of cell, gene and tissue (CGT) therapies that rely on these biologically derived components, known as substances of human origin (SoHO). However, many aspects of the institutional infrastructure are the same from facility to facility and country to country. With these precepts in mind, the authors called for the adoption of a new, universal management model to maximise the benefits of advanced therapy medicinal products (ATMPs).1

The study’s authors represented a number of institutions from multiple European countries, including Belgium, Finland, France, Ireland, the Netherlands and Spain. As a community, the authors wrote, stakeholders have a responsibility to produce safe, effective and affordable medicines, while also facilitating equity in patient access. This duty is shared by all members of the medical community, the authors emphasised, including “academic, non-profit, industrial, clinical, regulatory, patient advocacy or policy making representative(s).”

To establish more sustainable, equitable practices in the field of ATMPs, the authors proposed a new, intentional management model, called the “BTC for ATMP Development And Manufacture” (BADAM). Although a centralised authorisation procedure applies to ATMP development throughout the EU, there are additional regulatory pathways which exempt certain therapies from this authorisation. These factors, which are authorised on a national level, include named patient use, compassionate use and hospital exemption (HE). The two former exemption pathways enable patients with life-threatening medical needs to get early access to investigative ATMPs, without enrollment in a clinical trial. In certain controlled hospital environments, a practitioner may be able to prepare and deploy an HE on a “non-routine basis,” if it meets national compliance requirements and receives approval from a “competent authority” in the same Member State. Although these exemptions facilitate research and product development on a patient-by-patient basis, the regulatory restrictions limit collaboration and patient accessibility throughout the EU.

To offset the drawbacks of HE usage under Article 28(2) of the Regulation EU 1394/2007, the study’s authors suggested establishing a registry or database throughout the EU. A centralised registry would allow practitioners throughout Europe to better understand the magnitude of HE use in ATMPs, as well as which attributes (including clinical needs, financial resources and documentation requirements) motivate the use or disuse of these exemptions. As the authors noted, the level of documentation required for HE authorisation varies across the EU, as does the type of approval; some countries authorise specific products whereas others approve a range of ATMP products based on an establishment’s manufacturing license.1

The authors explained that limited financial viability of these individualised ATMPs narrows the range of institutions that can develop them. As a result, these SoHO-based therapeutics often fall into an “academic niche.” The authors explained, “HE has provided the regulatory niche for local manufacturing of ATMPs within an academic institution, including public facilities and non-profit organisations such as hospitals and BTCs.” The partnership between academia and BTC establishments is a vital basis for the BADAM model. The institutional knowledge held by these BTCs is crucial to the safe collection, transportation and storage of SoHO. Collaboration between BTC and nonprofit or research facilities can assist with donor recruitment and patient outreach initiatives as well. These BTCs could serve as regional “competence centres” if outfitted with additional financial, technological and human resources to “fill the gap” between industry regulations, health care providers and product manufacturers.

Rapid changes in the ATMP sector have resulted in a dearth of expertise. For example, some medical professionals working in a BTC setting may not have received adquate bioprocessing training for optimal performance in ATMP development. This subspecialty is understaffed and underserved, especially in roles such as pharmacists and technicians–and in the private sector, where ATMP development remains so limited. Along with strengthening the international data sharing between BTCs and ATMP developers, the authors also suggested bolstering the educational opportunities and requirements for ATMP development. “Training professionals on the particular needs of the CGT field is key to maintain a specialised workforce in the numbers required, albeit the global shortage of labor force,” the authors wrote. Intersectional, specialised postgraduate training programmes are an effective way to train this next generation of ATMP professionals, such as Sanquin in the Netherlands and Banc de Sang i Teixits in Spain, which support a joint master’s degree in transfusion medicine and cellular and tissue therapies coordinated by Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona (UAB) and Leiden University Medical Centre (LUMC).

In the United Kingdom, an initiative called the Advanced Therapy Manufacturing Industry Consortium (AToMIC) helps academic institutions prepare students for work in the ATMP field, and NHS Blood and Transplant has created learning modules specific to cell and gene therapy. But despite the institutional advancements in this area, BTCs are often overlooked as a viable development pathway for ATMP.

A diagram shows how ethical management addresses treatment and product dimensions.

The authors considered common assets of BTCs and the process of delivering custom treatment to patients as the basis for a centralised business model for ATMPs. The BADAM is a variant of the integrated business model described by Banda et al. “To fully realize BADAM [on] an international level, synergistic collaborations among BTCs are needed in almost all, if not all, segments of the value chain,” the authors said. Primarily, this requires a close working relationship between the “treatment dimension,” which is patient focused, and the “product dimension,” which is bioprocess focused (Figure). Scientific societies and professional organisations have an opportunity to support these BTC networks, and, in turn, become important stakeholders as member organisations invest in new ATMP development and production. Such initiatives are underway throughout the EU: ATMP Ireland, ATMP Sweden, Red Española de Terapias Avanzadas (TERAV) in Spain and AToMIC.

Intentional collaboration between BTCs and developing institutions can facilitate the development and application of novel CGT therapeutics across industries. In addition to the material impact of these endeavors, subsidiary benefits of the BADAM model include improved regulatory compliance, quality assurance, regional competence and research advancements. As technological capabilities for ATMPs improve at an exponential pace, this intentional institutional framework will increase patient access and improve treatment outcomes across the EU.

Reference

1. Delgadillo J, Kerkelä E, Waters A, et al. A management model in blood, tissue and cell establishments to ensure rapid and sustainable patient access to advanced therapy medicinal products in Europe. Cytotherapy. 2023 Sep 5:S1465-3249(23)01015-0. doi: 10.1016/j.jcyt.2023.08.001
Related Videos
ARVO 2024: Andrew D. Pucker, OD, PhD on measuring meibomian gland morphology with increased accuracy
 Allen Ho, MD, presented a paper on the 12 month results of a mutation agnostic optogenetic programme for patients with severe vision loss from retinitis pigmentosa
Noel Brennan, MScOptom, PhD, a clinical research fellow at Johnson and Johnson
ARVO 2024: President-elect SriniVas Sadda, MD, speaks with David Hutton of Ophthalmology Times
Elias Kahan, MD, a clinical research fellow and incoming PGY1 resident at NYU
Neda Gioia, OD, sat down to discuss a poster from this year's ARVO meeting held in Seattle, Washington
Eric Donnenfeld, MD, a corneal, cataract and refractive surgeon at Ophthalmic Consultants of Connecticut, discusses his ARVO presentation with Ophthalmology Times
John D Sheppard, MD, MSc, FACs, speaks with David Hutton of Ophthalmology Times
Paul Kayne, PhD, on assessing melanocortin receptors in the ocular space
Osamah Saeedi, MD, MS, at ARVO 2024
© 2024 MJH Life Sciences

All rights reserved.