Comparing aspheric IOLs

Article

George Beiko compares AMO's Tecnis and Alcon's IQ aspheric IOLs to establish which model provides the best vision.

Key Points

"A number of studies examining contrast sensitivity have already established the superiority of aspheric over traditional IOLs in terms of functional vision,"1–6 asserted Professor George Beiko, of McMaster University, Canada.

Aspheric IOLs provide better visual function because they correct the natural corneal spherical aberration, which, according to Professor Beiko, is 0.27–0.30 µm, on average. Correcting this aberration has been shown to improve contrast sensitivity; different aspheric lenses, however, aim to provide different levels of specific aberrations postoperatively, and there is no literature proving the most desirable degree of postoperative aberration.

How do the lenses compare?

AMO's Tecnis has a wavefront designed aspheric surface, and is a three-piece foldable, UV-blocking hydrophobic acrylic lens with an optimal refractive index of 1.47. It is available, in 0.5 D increments, for +10 to +30 D of correction.

Alcon's IQ lens has a posterior aspheric surface and a square edge; it is a one-piece foldable, UV-blocking and blue light-filtering hydrophobic acrylic lens with an optimal refractive index of 1.55. It is available, in 0.5 D increments, for +6 to +30 D of correction.

Both lenses have an overall lens length of 13.0 mm.

"The AMO lens targets a postop spherical aberration of 0.00 µm, whereas the Alcon lens's target is 0.10 µm," Professor Beiko explained. "We implanted the lenses into patients with corneal spherical aberrations of approximately 0.27 µm and compared the postoperative visual outcomes."

Measuring visual outcomes objectively

Forty patients with similar preoperative profiles were randomly assigned to receive either the Tecnis or the IQ lens. The spherical aberration of the anterior corneal surface had been determined using the Oculus Easygraph. To maintain consistency, a single surgeon using the same technique in each case was used to perform all the implantations. Each patient received the same postoperative care.

"At a minimum of eight weeks after the implantation, distance corrected contrast sensitivity was measured with an Optec 6500, and we used ANOVA analysis to compare all readings," Professor Beiko clarified.

"The study groups were found to be similar in terms of age, pupil size under photopic and mesopic conditions, post-op vision and post-op refractive error. According to our findings, there was a trend for the Tecnis group to outperform the IQ group under photopic conditions, but statistical significance was not reached," explained Professor Beiko (Figure 1/Table 2). However, under mesopic conditions, the Tecnis group had greater contrast sensitivity at 3, 12 and 18 cpd (p = 0.05) and at 6 pcd (p = 0.10) (Figure 2/Table 3).























Tecnis offers superior outcomes

Overall, the results tended to show that implanting an aspheric IOL that aimed to produce a smaller postoperative spherical aberration provided a better mean contrast sensitivity result and sharper vision.

"In terms of provision of functional vision, we therefore found the AMO Tecnis IOL to be the superior lens," Professor Beiko concluded.

---------

Special ContributorGeorge H. H. Beiko, BM, BCh, FRCSC is an assistant clinical professor of ophthalmology at McMaster University, Ontario, Canada. He may be reached by E-mail: george.beiko@sympatico.ca
Professor Beiko has disclosed financial relationships with AMO and Alcon Laboratories.

References

1. M. Packer, et al. J. Refract. Surg. 2002;18:692–696.

2. U. Mester, et al. J. Cataract Refract. Surg. 2003;29(4):652–660.

3. R.M. Kershner. J. Cataract Refract. Surg. 2003;29(9):1684–1694.

4. H. Kennis, et al. Bull. Soc. Belge Ophtalmol. 2004;294:49–58.

5. A. Martinez Palmer, et al. Arch. Soc. Esp. Oftalmol. 2005;80(2):71–78.

6. R. Bellucci, et al. J. Cataract Refract. Surg. 2005;31:712–717.

Newsletter

Join ophthalmologists across Europe—sign up for exclusive updates and innovations in surgical techniques and clinical care.

Recent Videos
Christine Curcio, PhD, of the University of Alabama at Birmingham Heersink School of Medicine, shares histology update and revised nomenclature for OCT with Sheryl Stevenson of the Eye Care Network and Ophthalmology Times
SriniVas R. Sadda, MD, FARVO, shares key points from his retina presentation at the International SPECTRALIS Symposium
Robert Sergott, MD, describes fluorescence lifetime imaging ophthalmoscopy (FLIO) and the International SPECTRALIS Symposium – And Beyond (ISS) in Heidelberg, Germany.
Rayaz Malik, MBChB, PhD, a professor of medicine at Weill Cornell Medicine - Qatar, spoke with Ophthalmology Times Europe about his presentation. It's titled "An eye on neurodegenerative diseases: Challenging the dogma" at the International SPECTRALIS Sympsoium. In conversation with Hattie Hayes, Ophthalmology Times Europe
Anat Loewenstein, MD, describes her presentation on remote imaging for age-related macular degeneration and geographic atrophy at the International SPECTRALIS Symposium, in conversation with Hattie Hayes of Ophthalmology Times Europe
Tyson Brunstetter, OD, PhD, a US Navy Aerospace Optometrist at the NASA Johnson Space Center in Houston, Texas, shares key takeaways from his keynote at the International SPECTRALIS Symposium (ISS)
Rayaz Malik, MBChB, PhD, shares his presentation, titled An eye on neurodegenerative diseases: Challenging the dogma, at this year's International SPECTRALIS Symposium
At the Retina World Congress, Siegfried Priglinger, MD, speaks about ensuring the best outcomes for preschool-aged patients
At the 2025 ASCRS meeting, Robert Ang, MD said small aperture IOLs can benefit all patients, especially those with complex corneas or who have undergone previous corneal refractive surgery
Viha Vig, MBChB graduate student at the University of Auckland, New Zealand, discusses her poster presentation on the relationship between mitochondiral disease, Alzheimer disease, and other types of dementia.
© 2025 MJH Life Sciences

All rights reserved.